Two top-ranking Democrats in the U.S. Senate are asking the U.S. Department of Labor to investigate Florida’s failure to process and pay out unemployment claims.
In a letter to the department’s inspector general sent Monday, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer of New York and Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon, the ranking Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, wrote that Florida’s failures stand out even among other states that have struggled to pay their out-of-work residents.
“While all states have seen record increases in the number of its residents applying for unemployment,” their letter states, “the state of Florida’s performance has proved uniquely poor in its abject inability to assist millions of Florida residents who have applied for and continue to await unemployment benefits.”
The senators are asking U.S. Labor Department Inspector General Scott Dahl to investigate Florida’s problems and look at whether state officials have been properly distributing federal aid for the coronavirus crisis. The CARES Act allotted billions for states to distribute to unemployed Americans. It also included $25 million for Dahl’s office to audit and investigate how states have handled that money.
During a news conference in Doral on Monday, Gov. Ron DeSantis dismissed the senators’ request as “partisan politics.”
“I’ve never heard of partisan politics in Washington, D.C., before,” said DeSantis, a former congressman. “Oh, my goodness, can you imagine that?
“These guys are very partisan,” he added. “That’s all they’re doing.”
DeSantis has already ordered his inspector general to look into the unemployment system, he noted Monday.
But his investigation, announced last month, appears focused on the decisions and actions of former Republican Govs. Charlie Crist and Rick Scott. DeSantis has said he wants to know how the state decided to spend $77 million on an unemployment system that he has said was designed to fail. The Department of Economic Opportunity selected Deloitte Consulting to build the state unemployment website in the closing months of Crist’s administration, in 2010. Scott’s administration oversaw the design, development and disastrous 2013 rollout of the system.
DeSantis hinted Monday that his investigation is not close to being finished.
“It’s going to take time, because this was a procurement process, there was funding,” he said. “This took place over a number of years.”
Unlike DeSantis’ investigation, Schumer and Wyden requested that the federal inspector general also look into how the system has been performing over the last several months, as the state has struggled to process the nearly 2.4 million claims it has received. During the first month of the crisis, Florida was the slowest state in the nation to process claims and was the only state in the nation to see its trust fund increase.
More than 1.2 million people have started to receive payments and $4.6 billion has been paid out, but systemic problems still exist. Many Floridians have been paid just a fraction of what they’re owed. Others are locked out of their accounts or have applications still marked “pending.” The state’s website crashes regularly, and state officials started rationing the number of people who can use it last week.
By comparison, New York, which has 2 million fewer residents than Florida, had paid out more than $10 billion in benefits by May 20.
Schumer and Wyden noted that even DeSantis has criticized Florida’s unemployment website, known as CONNECT.
The senators are asking federal investigators to take a deeper dive into Florida’s system, including why problems that were flagged repeatedly in three state audits, including one after DeSantis took office, were never fixed. A Politico story last week also noted that DeSantis’ transition team warned him the system could fail.
“Despite the system’s well documented problems, inaction from both current and past gubernatorial administrations in Florida left [the Florida Department of Economic Opportunity] completely unprepared to respond to record increases in unemployment claims caused by a pandemic,” the letter states. “Florida Governor Ron DeSantis recently stated that the program was ‘designed with all these different things, basically to fail’ and acknowledged that more changes are needed.
“Drastic improvements are needed, and it is unclear what steps are being taken immediately to mitigate the possibility of future failures in [Florida’s] unemployment processing system.”
The inspector general does not have to honor the senators’ request.
This story was originally published June 08, 2020 5:00 AM.